San Antonio Express-NewsHearst Newspapers Logo

'Serious deficiency' in shale's health providers

By , San Antonio Express-NewsUpdated
Mike Fisher

The counties in the Eagle Ford Shale oil and gas play struggle with a “serious deficiency” in the number of health care providers and a shortage of ambulance services, according to a study being released this week.

An increase in vehicle wrecks and workplace injuries — along with other health and social factors — have only exacerbated the need.

The assessment, a two-year effort by researchers at the University of Texas at San Antonio's Institute for Economic Development and paid for by Methodist Healthcare Ministries, found an 18-county area — a big swath of the shale region — is seeing a “sharp increase” in the need for emergency care, women's health services, pediatric care and specialty health services.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

“In a lot of these cases, we're talking about traditionally some of the poorest counties in the state, if not the country,” said Thomas Tunstall, research director of the UTSA institute. “So health care-related issues are not new to these areas. But all of the activity associated with the Eagle Ford Shale made the need for a study even more compelling.”

The findings, detailed in a 96-page document titled South Texas Community Medical Needs Assessment, take a close look at the medical needs and health infrastructure in an area spanning nearly 24,000 square miles, including Gonzales, DeWitt, Karnes, Wilson, Atascosa, Live Oak, McMullen, Frio, La Salle, Zavala and Dimmit counties. It also examined counties on the periphery of the shale play, such as Bexar, Bee, Edwards, Kinney, Uvalde, Maverick and Webb.

Public officials will discuss the findings at an all-day forum at the UTSA Downtown Campus on Friday.

The 18 counties collectively had an estimated population of more than 2.2 million in 2010, but that number is projected to reach 3 million to 4 million by 2050, according to the report.

Yet some of the rural areas still have limited health care resources. Six of the counties have no hospitals in their jurisdictions. Some counties have low numbers of clinics, while one — McMullen — has no clinics or doctors at all. Bexar County has the only family planning services among all of the counties, researchers found.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

“In some areas, the only medical personnel are nurses associated with schools, retirement homes or jails,” the study states. “In addition, locales that are served by a single physician who is either recently retired or near retirement struggle to recruit replacements.

“Despite the existence of public policy and government-sponsored programs, such as Medicare/Medicaid and affordable insurance, if there is no doctor, there is no care,” the study concludes.

Add to this a part-time workforce of nearly 360,000 people that is mostly uninsured, and it's apparent why emergency rooms at some rural hospitals are feeling the effects. Some counties, the report said, exhaust their annual funding for indigent health care in just weeks. One hospital administrator, who was not identified in the report, said its funds for uncompensated care are normally gone by the end of January and that its costs for such care have doubled from $1 million to $2 million monthly.

“All of this activity in the Eagle Ford has put a lot of pressure on the existing health care facilities, which were really already lacking,” Tunstall said.

Emergency medical services also have been strained. “The need for first responders was probably the most apparent,” Tunstall said.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

“In a lot of cases, the first responders in some of these counties were volunteer. ... Obviously, you can only tap volunteers so much,” he said, noting some volunteer EMS squads began hiring paid personnel to keep up with demand.

One Methodist Healthcare Ministries official said Monday that she was not surprised by any of the researchers' findings.

“Disparity in health care is not new to South Texas,” said Rebecca Brune, the nonprofit's vice president of strategic planning and growth.

The study found that the biggest increases in traffic accidents occurred in McMullen, Karnes and La Salle counties, based on data from 2009 through 2011. McMullen County saw the most dramatic change, with a fivefold increase in wrecks during that period.

McMullen County also experienced the biggest increase in workplace injuries among the 18 counties from 2010 to 2011, jumping nearly 400 percent, the report shows. McMullen County has the Olmos and Wilcox formations, which researchers said makes the county a key area for the shale's development.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

McMullen County also had the fewest health care professionals among the 18 counties, researchers found, while Live Oak County experienced a decline in the number of primary care physicians and licensed occupational therapists. Zavala County saw its number of EMS workers decline.

The report suggests that rural areas of the shale region might be better served by telemedicine — a technology that allows patients in remote areas to consult with physicians through a live video link after health care professionals have recorded the patients' vital signs and other necessary information. Other options include public-private partnerships and incentives for health care providers, the study said.

Cellphone coverage in the rural areas is critical for the development of new health care facilities, the study noted.

Because the Eagle Ford Shale's production is projected to last 20 to 30 years, the report suggests that officials would be “shortsighted” to do nothing because of assumptions that such growth will eventually slow.

Methodist Healthcare Ministries, which helps fund medical care and other health needs for low-income and uninsured people in South Texas, hopes the study will prompt conversation about the gaps in health services and how to plan for the future, Brune said.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

“There's been a tremendous amount of conversation around water and transportation, the environment, air quality. And I think health care is just as critical,” Brune said. “And I think it's all of those integrated to really create sustainable solutions.”

pohare@express-news.net

|Updated

Peggy O’Hare reports on the census, demographics and more. She joined the Express-News in April 2013. She is a former reporter at the Houston Chronicle, where she worked for 11 years. She is a graduate of Texas A&M University. Email Peggy at pohare@express-news.net.